Wisconsin (and Oregon) Cheddar Beer Soup

Soup

While doing research for my upcoming post for the Weekend Cookbook Challenge next Monday, I pulled out a cookbook I got a couple of years ago but have never made anything out of before — Prairie Home Cooking by Judith M. Fertig. I got this book by accident, through the Good Cook Club, when I didn’t return the response card in time. This is a problem that has been plaguing me ever since the Music Club fiasco of ’86 when I ended up with that Whitney Houston record.

But this accident was actually a useful one. I pulled down Prairie Home Cooking the other day and there were quite a few recipes that looked good to me. This one especially caught my eye. Being a Chicago native, I have had Cheese Beer soup before (mmmmmm…cheese and beer….mmmmmm) and I was perfectly happy to recreate the experience here in Portland.

Wisconsin Cheddar Beer Soup:
2 tbsp unsalted butter
2 tbsp AP flour
1/4 cup chopped yellow onion (I used white)
1/2 cup thinly-sliced celery
1/4 tsp cayenne pepper (I would actually reduce this to a dash, taste, and add more if needed)
1/4 tsp dry mustard
1 cup milk
1 1/2 cups full-bodied beer (1 bottle)
2-3 cups shredded cheddar cheese
1 tsp paprika
salt and pepper to taste
Garnish: garlic croutons

What justifies the Oregon in the title you ask?

beer and cheese

Tillamook and Bridgeport, of course!

Okay, so, melt the butter in a soup pot over medium heat. Add the onion and celery and sauté until soft, about 6-8 minutes.

onions

Stir in the flour and cook, stirring, for 2 more minutes. Add the cayenne and mustard and stir to combine. As I mentioned above, I would add a bit less of the cayenne and add more later if needed.

Next, whisk in the milk and beer. Bring the soup to a boil while continuing to whisk over medium high heat. For the beer, I would recommend a good amber ale. Darker beer seems to overpower the soup and a very light beer would be too under-whelming. The Ebenezeer Ale seemed okay, as that’s what I had on hand, but next time, just a plain ol’ amber will do.

whisking

Reduce the heat and simmer, uncovered, until the soup has thickened — about 15 minutes. Remove from heat and stir in the cheddar and paprika, until the cheese has melted and incorporated into the soup. Taste and adjust seasonings. Serve while hot with garlic croutons if you have some on hand.

7 Replies to “Wisconsin (and Oregon) Cheddar Beer Soup”

  1. R:
    Yep, you’re right! Thanks for catching that! Sometimes I am sleepy when I type my posts up! 🙂
    I went and checked, it’s 2 tbsp flour. It’s in the ingredient list now!

  2. I was searching for a pork loin recipe today & ran across your blog. I’ve been here for over an hour now. I grew up in Chicago, lived in Portland (left before you moved there), and live in Arizona with my husband.
    My husband no longer buys me presents for holidays, he just drives me to the Le Creuset outlet store and carries my cast iron to the car.
    I have friends that live on 44th Avenue, just south of Hawthorne.
    Thanks to you, I just took an hour vacation to Portland and loved every minute of it. I’ll be back to visit regularly.
    Marci

  3. Marci: Wow, that’s an awesome birthday tradition you and the hubby have at Le Creuset. jwa, are you reading this??!
    I’m so glad you’ve enjoyed my blog and hope you will be back! I guess the Chicago-Arizona-Portland is a popular combination 🙂

  4. I’m really sorry to burst everybody’s bubble, but in the interest of consumer reports–I tried to use this recipe and the soup curdled. It became a disgusting and of course unusable mess. I’ve made a similar soup before (it called for chicken or vegitable stock), and it came out fine. I don’t know whether maybe you left out an important ingrediant or step?
    Anyway, as it stands, the recipe may prove disastrous.
    Hungry In Madison

  5. Kate:
    I rechecked the recipe from the book and I didn’t forget anything. I’m really sorry it didn’t work out for you 🙁
    I’m trying to think back to anything that could have made a difference — I used 2% milk (I know fat helps prevent curdling).
    Another idea to help prevent curdling is to maybe add the beer, simmer, add the cheese and add the milk last? That might help.
    There’s always an element of mystery and danger when heating dairy. Like you suggest, stock may be the best option here to make sure it turns out.
    Anyway, again, I’m very sorry it didn’t work out.

Comments are closed.